There's several newer 883's in the local area, one has the 1200 kit. Aesthetically, I'd take an old Sporty over the newer ones. The new ones look too "tidy", somewhat boring & they don't even leak oil anymore...what's up with that ? LMAO!
Comparison-wise ? I'll take the 450 Rebel with the more classic styling. Performance-wise ? These 450's will do anything a stock 883 can. Now, the 1200 kit does bump 'em up a bit, but that only means they'd get the speeding ticket faster than us...hehehe....
Was riding with my bud, he on his 883, me on the Reb & right after we fired up the bikes & were just heading towards the road, this old greybeard came up to me & asked what year the Reb was. Told him it was an '86 & he said, "I figured it was an older bike, it has more class than that new one (nodding to the 883)". My bud was at the curb & didn't even see the conversation happening

. Told the guy I'd done a few mods & opened up the pipes to let her breathe a bit more & he smiled & said "Yeah, it'll easily keep up with 'that' one", LMAO!
(Shame on me for preferring the 450 Rebel & for criticizing the newer 883's a bit, but it's been a long winter!

)